Constructor: Freddie ChengRelative difficulty: Easy (2:47, and that's with a cocktail in me)
THEME: ON THAT NOTE ... (63A: Speaking of which ... or where the starts of 16-, 30- and 45-Across can be found?) — first words of themers are types of musical "notes":
Theme answers:- NATURAL LAW (16A: Universal code of ethics)
- SHARP COOKIE (30A: Quick-minded sort)
- FLAT-EARTHER (45A: One who says that you're not on the ball?)
Word of the Day: MARIE KONDO (
10D: Organizing guru who asks "Does it spark joy?") —
Marie Kondo (近藤 麻理恵, Kondō Marie, pronounced [maɾie kon.do], born 9 October 1984), also known as Konmari (こんまり), is a Japanese organizing consultant, author, and TV show host.Kondo has written four books on organizing, which have collectively sold millions of copies around the world. Her books have been translated from Japanese into several languages including Korean, Chinese, Spanish, Indonesian, Italian, French, German, Swedish, Portuguese, Catalan, and English. In particular, her book The Life-Changing Magic of Tidying Up (2011) has been published in more than 30 countries. It was a best-seller in Japan and in Europe, and was published in the United States in 2014.
In the United States and the United Kingdom, the profile of Kondo and her methods were greatly promoted by the success of the Netflix series Tidying Up with Marie Kondo, released in 2019, which gained Kondo a nomination for the Primetime Emmy Award for Outstanding Host for a Reality or Competition Program.
She was listed as one of Time's "100 most influential people" in 2015. (wikipedia)
• • •
As revealers go, this one (
ON THAT NOTE) is a little awkward. The "starts" of the themers aren't really "ON" anything, and the the "THAT" feels gratuitous. What note? You mean the theme answers
start (not "can be found") on
a note. Which, admittedly, does not really have revealer flair or panache, but if your revealer doesn't stick the landing, don't use it don't use it don't use it. I have looked the themers over a few times now to make sure that NATURAL, FLAT, and SHARP and not, in fact, "on" anything (well, they are "on"
ASHIER,
ROSE, and CHEZ, but I doubt that's meaningful). So, basically you have a very old old concept (first words are the three types of musical notes, undoubtedly used in many many puzzle themes over the years), and you've added this revealer twist. If the revealer were great, great. If not, not. Today, not so much. Also, the grid could be much cleaner and more thoughtfully filled. You (yes, you, probably) could get rid of the name
part (
GOGH) and the tired old mockery of the blind (
MAGOO) and the equally tiresome leering (
OGLE) and the geographical crosswordese (
ETNA) and the crosswordese crosswordese (
INRE) and the comically un-tilde'd crosswordese (
AÑO) without the aid of software, without too much effort. Who knows what you could do with a lot of effort? I did two different versions (a quick fix, and a more extensive Shoving a "J" and a "Q" and an "X" into the corners of your grid doesn't make it good—polishing every little part of it does.
On the plus side, the long Downs are fantastic today. Really original. I'm surprised I haven't seen KONDO's name in puzzles more. Seems like a very useful 5. I'm not sure if I knew that a
COMPACT SUV was a category (I've heard "small SUV," I think), but it looks like "compact" and "small" are fairly interchangeable. Anyway, I just like how
COMPACTSUV looks in the grid. Had the COMPACT and thought "... car?" but no. Better. More surprising as a crossword answer. Weirder to parse. Good. The center of the grid is solid too. Great words, no filler, no junk, great movie ("
PSYCHO!"), all bookended by the spiffy 7s
BAZOOKA and (fittingly) "
HOW NICE!").
Only a couple additional complaints, both of them particular to my specific tastes. 1. I am never going to accept that
YENS is a verb no matter how many times crosswords (or dictionaries) tell me it is. You have a yen for something, you don't yen for it. You can just say "yearn" if you really like the "y" sound. "Yearn" is also just one syllable and has the virtue of being a real non-pretend verb people use. And 2. I hate when just one themer has a "?" clue. I'm never going to not see that as a flaw. If it's a "?"-type theme, then they all have "?" clues. But if it's not, making just one of them a "?" clue is aesthetically displeasing. Too bad, as
FLAT-EARTHER is possibly the best answer in the grid. But the corny aint-I-clever outlier "?" clue
(45A: One who says that you're not on the ball?) really deflated the
FLAT-EARTHER experience for me. It also made that answer by far the hardest thing to get in the grid, and (consequently?) the last answer I got.
Signed, Rex Parker, King of CrossWorld
[Follow Rex Parker on
Twitter and
Facebook]