Constructor: Aimee Lucido and Ella Dershowitz
Relative difficulty: Easy
THEME: DOUBLE CROSS (69A: Betray ... or a hint to four answers in this puzzle)— familiar phrases containing numbers appear in the grid with that number halved ... but then the number actually crosses the letter string "TWO," so ... crosses "TWO" = x 2 = doubled. The "TWO" cross doubles the number back to what it's supposed to be, hence "DOUBLE CROSS":
Theme answers:
There's a cleverness to this concept, but ultimately it's a bit one-note, and the theme feels very thin. I get that the "TWO" crosses mean that there are really technically eight theme answers (besides the revealer), but it doesn't feel that way. It feels like four, and four is thin. Also, once you grok the concept, there's not much left to discover, and no real new cleverness left to discover. 2x1 is 2, 2x2 is 4, and so on. You could just go down to all the themers you didn't have yet and get them pretty easily. The issue isn't just "does it work?" but "is it fun? is it joyful? does it hold surprises?" There just wasn't enough oomph to this one for me. Some of this flatness could've been made up for in the fill, but the grid is not built in such a way that allows for a lot of longer, showier answers. POP A WHEELIE (118A: Be up for some biking?) and LOUDMOUTH (25A: Blabberer) definitely give the grid some life, but mostly what you have is a very choppy, black-squarey grid and (consequently) a preponderance of shorter answers; thus, not a lot of especially lively fill (though the overall quality is more than sufficiently smooth and solid). The best, most creative moments actually come in the various "TWO"-containing answers. Kinda tough to make that work out for times, crossing the appropriate number each time, and as you can see, difficulty often leads to cool innovation; "JUST ... WOW"(82D: "I. Can't. Even.") is the very best example of this, though "IT WORKS" (80D: "Success!") is also inventive. The theme concept is sturdy, but it doesn't lead to a ton of solving joy. I found myself wishing the whole experience were, I don't know, PERKIER, maybe?
Relative difficulty: Easy
Theme answers:
- ONE-FACED (27A: Duplicitous) (i.e. two-faced) (x/w ATWOOD)
- TWO-LETTER WORDS (i.e. four-letter words) (52A: #$%& and @%¢!) (x/w ATWORST)
- THREE FEET UNDER (i.e. six feet under) (85A: Pushing up daisies) (x/w "ITWORKS!")
- FOUR BALL (i.e. eight ball) (113A: What the beleaguered are behind) (x/w "JUSTWOW")
Will Eno (born 1965) is an American playwright based in Brooklyn, New York. His play, Thom Pain (based on nothing) was a finalist for the Pulitzer Prize in Drama in 2005. His play The Realistic Joneses appeared on Broadway in 2014, where it received a Drama Desk Special Award and was named Best Play on Broadway by USA Today, and best American play of 2014 by The Guardian. His play The Open House was presented Off-Broadway at the Signature Theatre in 2014 and won the Obie Award for Playwriting as well as other awards, and was on both TIME Magazine and Time Out New York 's Top Ten Plays of 2014. (wikipedia)
• • •
Not really a fan of the longer-than-themers non-theme answers which are always awkward to my eye and occasionally (as they were today) slightly confusing. The first long Across even has a "?" clue, so both its size and it's "?" scream "THEME!" but then ... no. Anticlimax. It's just WIRETAPPING, and WIRETAPPING has nothing to do with the theme, despite being the longest answer in the top quarter of the grid. I think the relative smallness of ONEFACED and FOURBALL are also contributing to my sense that the theme material is thin. There aren't really any particularly vexing clues today, and no answers (besides the non-Brian ENO) that were unknown to me. My brain is currently nibbling on the weirdness of the fact that DON'T ASK (26D: Response to "How bad was it?") is one letter-removal away from ON TASK. Last week it was nibbling on the fact that HIDEOUS is one letter change, one letter step, in fact, from HIDEOUT. Tiny structural changes that result in big meaning changes are very much my jam. But none of this has anything to do with the crossword per se. My apologies. I just don't have much else to say here. I hope you grooved on this one more than I did.
Signed, Rex Parker, King of CrossWorld
[Follow Rex Parker on Twitter and Facebook]
Signed, Rex Parker, King of CrossWorld
[Follow Rex Parker on Twitter and Facebook]