Constructor: Zachary David Levy
Relative difficulty: Easy-Medium (solved Downs-only) (finished with an error, though)
THEME: TRIPLE WORD SCORE (58A: Coveted Scrabble space ... or the sheet music for 16-, 21-, 34- or 51-Across?) — song titles where a single word is tripled:
Theme answers:
This is one I definitely appreciated more when I got the revealer *and* looked at the theme-answer clues. Before that, solving Downs-only, it was just a lot of repeated-word phrases, and even when I got TRIPLE WORD SCORE, I didn't see the musical connection. But now, seeing that all the theme answers are songs, the "SCORE" pun becomes clear. I think of "SCORE" as music composed for a movie, but it's also just the "copy of a musical composition in printed or written notation" (merriam-webster dot com). I also think of "sheet music" as primarily orchestral—it's definitely not a phrase I'd put anywhere near Mötley Crüe, for instance—but there's "sheet music" for all kinds of music (even "GIRLS, GIRLS, GIRLS"), so even though the "sheet music" bit feels a *little* preposterous, on a technical level, it works. The theme is, by its nature, repetitive, and those theme answers were (therefore) really easy to get solving Downs-only, but still, conceptually, with *that* revealer, it's pretty good.
Bullets:
Signed, Rex Parker, King of CrossWorld
[Follow Rex Parker on Twitter and Facebook]
Relative difficulty: Easy-Medium (solved Downs-only) (finished with an error, though)
Theme answers:
- "GIMME GIMME GIMME" (16A: Abba hit of 1979)
- "BYE BYE BYE" (21A: 'N Sync hit of 2000)
- "GIRLS GIRLS GIRLS" (34A: Mötley Crüe hit of 1987)
- "FUN FUN FUN" (51A: Beach Boys hit of 1964)
The Namib (/ˈnɑːmɪb/ NAH-mib; Portuguese: Namibe) is a coastal desert in Southern Africa. According to the broadest definition, the Namib stretches for more than 2,000 kilometres (1,200 mi) along the Atlantic coasts of Angola, Namibia, and northwest South Africa, extending southward from the Carunjamba River in Angola, through Namibia and to the Olifants River in Western Cape, South Africa. The Namib's northernmost portion, which extends 450 kilometres (280 mi) from the Angola-Namibia border, is known as Moçâmedes Desert, while its southern portion approaches the neighboring Kalahari Desert. From the Atlantic coast eastward, the Namib gradually ascends in elevation, reaching up to 200 kilometres (120 mi) inland to the foot of the Great Escarpment. Annual precipitation ranges from 2 millimetres (0.079 in) in the aridest regions to 200 millimetres (7.9 in) at the escarpment, making the Namib the only true desert in southern Africa. Having endured arid or semi-arid conditions for roughly 55–80 million years, the Namib may be the oldest desert in the world and contains some of the world's driest regions, with only western South America's Atacama Desert to challenge it for age and aridity benchmarks. (wikipedia)
• • •
The fill on this one seemed far far less good. I tripped all over myself trying to make sense of the NAMIB / IN-APP / GAEL / ALY part as I started the puzzle (and really winced at ALY, considering I'd *just* written in ALI). And oof, the partials. A LEAK!? Trying to make sense of that when I couldn't see the Across clues was painful. It would've been painful, if somewhat easier, even if I could've seen the clue—it's really a horrible partial, and then we get *another* very bad-feeling partial?!? ("I'M OF"). Why the hell does a supremely easy Monday puzzle have two egregious partials? The craftsmanship really should be better—the fill much smoother—on early-week puzzles. But I had to stumble through stale and bygone fill of all kinds. "I CAME"? Ugh, I'm calling that a "partial" too, that makes three, that's too many. LUV, PRE, SCI, GAR ... OLA!? OXO? There's way way too much subpar stuff. ORES and OARS, ABUT and ATOP, SSW and SFPD ... these are innocuous on their own, but today they're part of a tidal wave of gunk. When my Downs-only adventures left me with T-SHAPE (!?!?!?), I sincerely thought I had something wrong.
There was almost no part of the solve where I thought things looked polished, bright, and clean. And after suffering through all the unloveliness, I ended up with an error, ugh. I had RIP BY instead of ZIP BY because RUMBA looked so good (in a way that ZUMBA, which I haven't heard anyone refer to in well over a decade, absolutely does not). I guess ZIP BY is more of a real phrase than RIP BY, but RUMBA > ZUMBA (in my head). Also, the "quickly fly past" in the clue made it seem like the clue was referring to time, and the years really do RIP BY as you get older, so honestly, I didn't really blink at that "R." Bah and humbug.
Bullets:
- 14A: Popular dance fitness program (ZUMBA) — is it, though? Popular? It seems about as "popular" as TAE BO, which I *also* encounter exclusively in crosswords (and thrift stores that sell VHS tapes from the '90s). I get whatever "fitness" I have from going to the gym (2x/week) and running. I ran my first 10K yesterday. Very slowly (finished 9th out of 11 in my gender/age category), but I did it.
- 43A: Pennsylvania governor Josh (SHAPIRO) — it took a Vice Presidential sweepstakes for me to learn the name of the governor of the Giant State Located About Ten Miles South Of My House. Even though SHAPIRO wasn't Harris's ultimate choice, seems like his profile was raised quite a bit this summer. And yet not so much that he's the Top SHAPIRO in my brain. Since I solved Downs-only, I couldn't see the SHAPIRO clue, and so I assumed (given the NYTXW's eternal love for all things NPR) that the SHAPIRO in question would be Ari.
- 4D: Coastal African desert (NAMIB) — putting this together without Acrosses was rough. I just had a hard time convincing myself that NAMIB was a thing. I wrote it in and then stared at it like "er ... uh ... I dunno ... am I misremembering that? It looks ... bad." But nope, it's good. The trivia-retrieval part of my brain is still minimally operative. Good to know.
- 24D: Man's name that's a fruit spelled backward (EMIL) — All the MULPs out there are like "Damn! It's EMIL again. Some day ..."
- 39D: Athleisure lead-in to "lemon" (LULU)— If there's an uglier fashion word than "athleisure," I don't know what it is. It sounds like an affliction, not a clothing type. Like lesions you get from athletics, maybe. I know LULUlemon (one word? ... yes, one word) as a popular brand of yoga apparel. I guess they've branched out. The LULU really doesn't stand on its own. If you need a self-standing LULU, may I suggest ...
- 60D: Kitchen brand with a palindromic name (OXO) — at least we're spared the "Losing tic-tac-toe" line of cluing today. Small blessings.
See you next time.
[Follow Rex Parker on Twitter and Facebook]