Constructor: Robyn Weintraub
Relative difficulty: Medium
THEME: none
Word of the Day: ETHEL Barrymore (1D: Actress Barrymore with an eponymous Broadway theater) —
Ah, I'd forgotten what these were like (these being Robyn Weintraub puzzles). Feels like it's been a while. Has it been a while? Wow, it really has. This is the first RW puzzle of 2024, according to my own 2024 spreadsheet. Her byline was last seen Dec. 29, 2023. Anyway, in case you didn't know because you are very new to puzzles, Robyn's Friday themeless crosswords are pretty much the Gold Standard, the ones that I'm measuring all others against, and today's puzzle is a good example of why—marquee answers for days (I count 12!?), and an overall flow that makes the puzzle a delight to move through. Whoosh. That's what they have. Or Zing, if you like. The best of the marquees tend to be (as they are today) colorful colloquial phrases, figures of speech that really give the grid some life ("THAT'S THE SPOT!""THERE'S MORE!""DON'T REMIND ME!"). There are actually only two flat-out debut answers today ("THAT'S THE SPOT!" and INSIDE JOBS), but debuts (while nice) aren't necessarily the goal. I've seen plenty of terrible debuts, where I thought, "Yes, the world was better when we were not putting that in puzzles." The goal is a feeling of freshness and a spirit of fun and a wide and varied palette of answers, all in a cleanly filled grid. And on those counts, this puzzle delivers. It's SMART! (30A: Stylish in appearance).
Notes:
Signed, Rex Parker, King of CrossWorld
[Follow Rex Parker on Twitter and Facebook]
Relative difficulty: Medium
Word of the Day: ETHEL Barrymore (1D: Actress Barrymore with an eponymous Broadway theater) —
Ethel Barrymore (born Ethel Mae Blythe; August 15, 1879 – June 18, 1959) was an American actress and a member of the Barrymore family of actors. Barrymore was a stage, screen and radio actress whose career spanned six decades, and was regarded as "The First Lady of the American Theatre". She received four nominations for the Academy Award for Best Supporting Actress, winning for None but the Lonely Heart (1944). // She was the sister of actors John and Lionel Barrymore, the aunt of actor John Drew Barrymore and great-aunt of actress Drew Barrymore. She was a granddaughter of actress and theater manager Louisa Lane Drew and niece of Broadway matinée idol John Drew, Jr. and Vitagraph Studios stage and screen star Sidney Drew. (wikipedia)
[None But the Lonely Heart]
• • •
The thing about smooth puzzles like this is that when I hit a bump, it really Bumps. Whether it's me or the puzzle itself that is clunking, rough spots become very memorable. Some combination of me and the puzzle clunking simultaneously made the start of this solve very awkward. I should've just written in ETHEL, because come on, what other actress besides DREW has that name, but I had already decided that an "intaglio" involved the act of TILE-ing, not ETCHing, and I had also decided that Queen Suthida Bajrasudhabimalalakshana was a RANI (crossword reflex!). I maybe should've recognized the name as THAI, but that's the problem, that, the way I used "THAI" just there—I would only ever use that word as an adjective. "She's a THAI"? I'm sure that's valid, but it is not at all intuitive to my ears. If the clue had been [Like Queen Suthida Bajrasudhabimalalakshana], RANI (a noun) would've been out, as would all nouns, and so THAI would likely have come to me sooner. This is like cluing GERMAN as [Werner Herzog, e.g.]. I want GERMAN to be an adjective, even though I know that it can be a noun. Cluing THAI as a noun, while technically legal, felt very awkward. Anyway, I'm mostly embarrassed that my first response here placed the Queen in an entirely different country. At least RANI is, in fact, the equivalent of "Queen." That makes my error slightly less mortifying.
[my neighborhood THAI place] |
Couldn't remember what "intaglio" was, couldn't identify the nationality of a queen—that pretty much gummed up the works in the NW, but I just moved over to the N where I found a NUDE, who kindly helped me get some real traction, and from that point, the Whoosh began—across the NE and then back over to the NW and then down to the SW and finally up the IRISES and over to the NATO SUMMIT, finishing up with not Kea but LOA (52D: "Mahalo nui ___" (Hawaiian for "Thank you very much")). After the TILE / RANI fiasco of the NW, only a couple of places really stood out as ugly or troublesome. I would call the sweater type a "crewneck," so 31D: Works on a crew? (DARNS) just didn't land for me. Needed every single cross. [correction: you darn socks, obviously, so this is a crew sock, which I have really Really never heard called just a “crew”]. I also have never really heard the term STEAM TABLE (except, apparently, in the NYTXW back in '09. Sounds like something you'd find at a spa. I can picture one, I guess, but maybe the buffets I've been to of late have used sterno as a heating element? Not really a buffet enthusiast, to be honest. But STEAM TABLEs are very real things—just beyond my ken (and general vocabulary). I wouldn't say ORE comes in "pockets" (29D: Things in pockets that can be picked?) (I've always been told—by the crossword!—that ORE comes in "seams"), nor would I say that a bridge "runs across" a river, say (see clue for SPANS (25A: Runs across)), but both clues are obviously trying (very hard) to misdirect you, and they're both technically valid, so OK. Not sure why there's a "?" on the ORE clue except to say "hey look at me doing some really bad 'pickpocket' wordplay." Maybe this clue just wanted to do a little "pocket" callback to the CARGO PANTS clue (3D: They have deep pockets). The misdirection on [Runs across] is more sly. That clue obviously wants you to think "Runs across" as in "Meets" or "Encounters." Mission accomplished.
Notes:
- 17A: Gather together (HERD) — an additional factor in the whole opening NW wipe-out. I wanted REAP ... maybe MASS.
- 45A: Emulates Niobe (MOURNS)— she's so strongly associated with tears that after CRIES wouldn't fit, I was out of ideas. But MOURNS, sure, that is what occasions the crying.
["Like Niobe, all tears"]
- 49A: "Ew, ew, EW!" ("TMI!")— "Too Much Information"; a really great clue. You can really feel the "stop talking now!" energy.
- 10D: Pair making an appearance in the "Iliad"? (IOTAS)— a "letteral" clue, with the referent being the two (Greek) "I"s in the word "Iliad." ["Iliad" pair] (no question mark) would've been wickeder.
- 13D: Best Actress nominee in 1992 who won Best Supporting Actress in 2020 (DERN) — it says something (bad? telling?) about my pop culture brain that without looking I could name the 1992 movie in question (Rambling Rose) but not the 2020 one. I thought maybe Certain Women (wrong year) or else Little Women, but she wasn't nominated for that (Ronin and Pugh were). Did you know she was also in Dr. T and the Women (2000)? This means that there is (unofficially, but now also canonically) a Laura DERN"Women" trilogy. Anyway, DERN won her Oscar for playing a divorce lawyer in Marriage Story.
[DR. T has made 27 NYTXW appearances to date, mostly for this movie ... though occasionally also for the freaky Seussian musical fantasy, The 5000 Fingers of DR. T (1953)] |
[Follow Rex Parker on Twitter and Facebook]