Constructor: Benjamin FinkRelative difficulty: Easy
THEME:"CAN YOU BELIEVE IT?!" (57A: "Isn't that mind-blowing?!" ... or a question on might ask about the answers to the italicized clues) — things you might be disinclined to believe:
Theme answers:- CAMPAIGN PROMISE (17A: "I will never raise your taxes!")
- CUSTOMER REVIEW (28A: "This product changed my life! Five stars!")
- HOMEWORK EXCUSE (44A: "The dog ate it!")
Word of the Day: Peter LORRE (
41A: Actor Peter of "M" and "The Man Who Knew Too Much") —
Peter Lorre (German: [ˈpeːtɐ ˈlɔʁə]; born László Löwenstein, Hungarian: [ˈlaːsloː ˈløːvɛ(n)ʃtɒjn]; June 26, 1904 – March 23, 1964) was a Hungarian and American actor, first in Europe and later in the United States. He began his stage career in Vienna, in the Austro-Hungarian Empire, before moving to Germany where he worked first on the stage, then in film in Berlin in the late 1920s and early 1930s. Lorre caused an international sensation in the Weimar Republic-era film M (1931), directed by Fritz Lang, in which he portrayed a serial killer who preys on little girls.Of Jewish descent, Lorre left Germany after Adolf Hitler and the Nazi Party came to power. His second English-language film, following the multiple-language version of M (1931), was Alfred Hitchcock's The Man Who Knew Too Much (1934), made in the United Kingdom. Eventually settling in Hollywood, he later became a featured player in many Hollywood crime and mystery films. In his initial American films, Mad Love and Crime and Punishment (both 1935), he continued to play murderers, but he was then cast playing Mr. Moto, the Japanese detective, in a B-picture series.
From 1941 to 1946, he mainly worked for Warner Bros. His first film at Warner was The Maltese Falcon (1941), the first of many films in which he appeared alongside actors Humphrey Bogart and Sydney Greenstreet. This was followed by Casablanca (1942), the second of the nine films in which Lorre and Greenstreet appeared together. (wikipedia)
• • •
Somehow the wordplay doesn't really seem to land. These are three arbitrary things one might not believe, and then there's this hypothetical question ... but is it a question "one might ask?" Who is one asking this question? Seems like, at a minimum, the revealer clue should have a "?" on the end of it, since the actual phrase, "
CAN YOU BELIEVE IT!?," is being applied to contexts where one would never actually ask this question. "Question one might ask ..." Who? Oneself? And is this a sincere question, or more a statement posing as a question? I might wonder *whether* I can believe campaign promises or customer reviews or homework excuses; I might ask myself if *I* believe it. But there's not even a completely banal way I can imagine someone actually asking this question using these words in this order. If I can't imagine the context, or the questioner's interlocutor, then the whole premise just kind of falls apart, or at least buckles. Like, I get it, these are not believable things, great. The revealer phrasing—or the clue phrasing—just doesn't hit the mark. Also, it's all just a little too straightforward and boring. The revealer I *wanted*, when I was solving Downs-only, was "DON'T YOU BELIEVE IT!"—an idiom that Merriam-Webster says is "
used to emphasize that one should not believe a statement or sentiment." It just made sense. It also, sadly, didn't fit. Neither did "DO YOU BELIEVE IT?!" I had to go pick up the "C" and "A" (from SCAR and LASH) before I could see the "CAN." It just doesn't snap the way it seems to believe it snaps.
Some of this fill is iffy too. WON ONE? Definite grimace on that ... one (45D: Claimed a victory, homophonically). The clue itself was a mystery. Nothing in it about the two words in the answer being homophones *of one another*, so I had to piece that bit together. And then the answer itself was WON ONE, which is pretty weak, as standalone answers go. EXOTICA was maybe the most interesting thing in the grid (42D: Rare things from far away), although I guess HAIRPIECES isn't bad (11D: Toupees, e.g.) (you don't really hear about these anymore—the very idea seems sorta bygone, but I've seen enough hairpiece gags in TV and cartoons of the 20th century that the answer still held some vaguely humorous charm for me) (I started losing my hair in my mid-twenties, and by my late '30s I was like "this sucks" and just shaved it all off—by that point, shaved heads were a totally normal, boring thing, hurrah) (if a balding person has hair nowadays, there's a good chance they REGREW it using some drug or topical chemical or god knows what that I have no interest in trying—too much hassle, not to mention the EXPENSE).
There were only a few Downs-only snags today. Well, one big one, right in the middle of the grid. Any time you ask me what key a symphony (or anything) is in, I just shrug, shake my head, and write in "blank M blank blank OR" and then hope for the best (24D: Key of Beethoven's Symphony No. 7). Next to the symphony were REMARKS and REGREW, neither of which immediately sprang to mind given their clues (25D: Comments / 30D: Sprouted anew). So I actually ended up finishing in this section, working up from below after I'd closed everything else out. I was a bit unsure of TECH (33D: Many an engineer's field, informally), but since it was the first thing I thought of, and it still worked after all the adjacent answers were filled in, I just went with it. I obviously couldn't do anything with -OM (10D: See 22-Across) until near the very end, since Downs-only means no looking at 22-Across. But ROM => COM, no problem, eventually (22A: With 10-Down, humorous film about love). The one issue that was slightly ambiguous, at the very very end, was still what key that damn symphony was in. NOT-R looked like it could be NOTER (one who notes? is E MAJOR a key?) but ultimately the vaping claim "NO TAR" seemed the more plausible candidate there (23A: Absence noted in vape pen ads), so I went with that, and was rewarded with the "Congratulations, you managed to finish a Monday puzzle, genius" message.
[3D: 1996's "Dancing Baby" might have been the first one to go viral => MEME]
Signed, Rex Parker, King of CrossWorld