Constructor: Robyn Weintraub
Relative difficulty: Easy-Medium
THEME: none
Word of the Day: RAUL Esparza (50A: Actor Esparza with four Tony nominations) —
This is pretty standard fare from Robyn Weintraub, which is to say, I really enjoyed it. It's a bit on the tame side for her, more solid than sizzling, but this is what happens when you set the bar so high—expectations go high too. The grid abounds in fresh longer answers, though only a couple have that chatty colloquial snap that really gives life to a puzzle—that is, the wonderful crossing of "TELL ME ABOUT IT!" and "THAT'S A FIRST." There's something kind of plain about most of the rest of the grid. GREENPEACE over RACEHORSES, OVERSTATED over FIESTA BOWL ... these are fine, but don't exactly make you sit up and say "Hell-o!" And yet the grid is still extremely smooth and clean, and I'd take it over 90% of other Friday grids any day. This was a fast solve for me, but my whoosh was slightly inhibited by longer answers where one or the other halves of them were hard to make out. So I'd drop "THAT'S..." and not know what followed. Or I'd get "-OUT IT" and think "well, 'NO DOUBT ABOUT IT' doesn't fit, so ... I dunno!" This isn't a complaint about the puzzle, by any means—in fact, those two answers I struggled with were, as I say, the best answers in the grid, so the struggle was very much worth it. I just never really got flying, and for the most part, the longer answers never really provided a roller-coaster thrill. Well, scratch that, I'm nerdy enough to have gotten something close to a thrill out of SERIAL COMMA (6D: Much-debated grammar topic). The NYT style guide is ANTI-. I tend to be pro-, but writing lots and lots in very short amounts of time has probably made me wildly inconsistent in practice. I just know there are times when not having a serial comma can make the exact nature of the terms in your list confusing. This may be my favorite real-life example of such confusion—from a newspaper account of a documentary about Merle Haggard:
Relative difficulty: Easy-Medium
Word of the Day: RAUL Esparza (50A: Actor Esparza with four Tony nominations) —
Raúl Eduardo Esparza (born October 24, 1970) is a Cuban-American stage, screen, and voice actor, as well as singer. Considered one of Broadway's leading men since the 2000s, he is best known for his Tony Award-nominated performance as Bobby in the 2006 Broadway revival of Company and for his television role as New York Assistant District Attorney (ADA) Rafael Barba in Law & Order: Special Victims Unit, where he had a recurring role in Season 14 and was promoted to a series regular in Seasons 15 to 19. [...] Esparza has been nominated in all Tony categories for which an actor is eligible. He is widely regarded for his versatility on stage, having performed musicals by Andrew Lloyd Webber, Stephen Sondheim, Kander and Ebb, Boy George, the Sherman Brothers and in plays by Mamet, Pinter, William Shakespeare, Tom Stoppard, and more. // His film work includes Sidney Lumet's Find Me Guilty and Wes Craven's My Soul to Take, and his television credits include roles on The Path, Medium, Hannibal and Pushing Daisies. He narrated the audiobook for Stephen King's Under the Dome as well as several others, and he sings in concerts across the country. (wikipedia)
• • •
["Among those interviewed were his two ex-wives, Kris Kristofferson and Robert Duvall". (nielsenhayden.com)] |
The puzzle is refreshingly free of obscurities and is mercifully unreliant on proper nouns ... which makes it sound like I don't like proper nouns, which I do, it's just you Know how those things can really divide an audience and make the same puzzle easy for some and brutal for others. Always sucks to get on the side of brutality. But today, no such side. The only proper nouns are in the connective tissue, tiny things like RYAN and RAUL (the only answer I wasn't familiar with). Sometimes those little answers can make a big difference, though. Today, for instance, I was saved by ANKA. I'd dropped ENLARGE down at 5D: Option in a photo editing app and I needed Paul to pull me out of that trap (thank you, Paul). I thought "ENHANCE!" was the easily parodied exclamation that investigators shout at blow-ups of grainy surveillance footage in TV shows. I did not know it was an actual "Option." Other things I didn't know ... not much. Took me a bit to figure out who this RYAN person was (he's the RYAN that comes after "Saving" and "Private") (18A: Title paratrooper in a 1998 war film). DOGSTAR also took me a bit because I was not taking the "familiarly" part of the clue seriously (39D: Brightest point in Canis Major, familiarly); or, rather, I was taking it ... Siriusly.
Definitely stalled (!) on the RACEHORSES clue (17A: Animals that all share the same "birthday" (January 1)). I guess the horses' actual birthdays don't matter for race classification purposes. I think I knew that, but it certainly didn't help me here. I had RACEL- (because of ENLARGE!), which wasn't getting me anywhere, so I was a bit slow right out of the gate (!!). Other, much smaller issues:
Issues!:
Signed, Rex Parker, King of CrossWorld
[Follow Rex Parker on Twitter and Facebook]
- 36A: Greek philosopher known for reductio ad absurdum arguments (ZENO) — some small part of me alllllllways wants to spell his name XENO (Warrior Prince!?).
- 49D: Without direction (IDLY)— hard / impossible to tell if this is going to be adjectival or adverbial. I went with adjectival but thankfully the cross was unambiguous (brie is RUNNY, not RUNNE).
- 11D: Laundry room detritus (DRYER SHEET) — "detritus" had me thinking of ... lots of things. That is, multiple things. Plurals. And SHEETS wouldn't fit, so I futzed about here for a bit until I realized I was just dealing with a singular, which is accurate enough, "detritus" being both the singular and the plural (see ... I dunno, "sheep?"). Also, I never know if it's DRIER or DRYER. I guess the former is the comparative adjective and the latter is the appliance? Yes, let's go with that.
See you tomorrow.
[Follow Rex Parker on Twitter and Facebook]