Quantcast
Channel: Rex Parker Does the NYT Crossword Puzzle
Viewing all articles
Browse latest Browse all 4351

Ancestral spirit in Pueblo mythology / SAT 3-4-23 / Decodable device featured in "The Da Vinci Code" / Over 95% of its residents live near a riverbank / Title lyric after Ours is a love in a 1950s hit / Component of a sake bomb often / Actress Chumsky of Veep / Spur of industry according to David Hume

$
0
0
Constructor: Ryan McCarty

Relative difficulty: Medium-Challenging


THEME: none 

Word of the Day: KACHINA (20A: Ancestral spirit in Pueblo mythology) —

kachina (/kəˈnə/; also katchinakatcina, or katsinaHopi:  katsina [kaˈtsʲina], plural katsinim [kaˈtsʲinim]) is a spirit being in the religious beliefs of the Pueblo peoplesNative American cultures located in the south-western part of the United States. In the Pueblo cultures, kachina rites are practiced by the HopiZuniHopi-Tewa, and certain Keresan tribes, as well as in most Pueblo tribes in New Mexico.

The kachina concept has three different aspects: the supernatural being, the kachina dancers, and kachina dolls (small dolls carved in the likeness of the kachina, that are given only to those who are, or will be responsible for the respectful care and well-being of the doll, such as a mother, wife, or sister).

• • •

Ryan McCarty is one of my favorite constructors, but this was not as enjoyable for me as most of his other puzzles have been, for a couple reasons. First, it felt very trivia-heavy. I am speaking with a certain seething self-recrimination at not having been able to remember the back end of GUINEA-BISSAU, it's true (5D: Neighbor of Senegal), but that one, plus names (almost exclusively TV/movie names) in every corner and cranny, made this one feel like a test to reward those with a certain fairly narrow pop culture sensibility and punish those without it. I knew half the names, but that's beside the point. On a personal note, asking me to know anything about The Da Vinci Code is always going to put me in a bad mood, and a fictional device (that is Not Clued As Fictional), yeah, that's ... not a crowd-pleaser when the crowd is me (11D: Decodable device featured in "The Da Vinci Code"). But beyond the trivia-ness is a general blandness in the longer answers. I think the big open center of this puzzle is impressively clean, and I kind of liked putting it together, but it's hard to get excited about stuff like PRESS ENTER (?) and ERROR MESSAGE. It was like being in Computer Science class in 1983 (only without the beautiful naive hope that all this computer stuff was going to end up making the world Awesome!). MAJOR ROLES, SOLO ARTIST ... there just wasn't as much of a spark to the marquee stuff as I'd normally like to see. There's no question about the overall smoothness and solidness of the grid, so I'm happy to concede that my generally disappointed feeling is probably simply a matter of taste, as well as a very very high level of expectation when it comes to this constructor's puzzles.


The puzzle was also hard, but it's supposed to be hard. It's Saturday. That said, it was definitely harder for me than most recent Saturdays have been. Not just hard, but a little scary, in that I got genuinely, alarmingly stuck in both of the small corners (not where I expected to get bogged down). Could get "Hot PASTRAMI" for the life of me, and wouldn't commit to CRYONIC for some reason—I knew CRYONICS was a word but wasn't sure about the "S"-less adjectival form. Anyway, not having these answers in place paved the way for a near-fatal error: instead of IDIOM / BASIC, I had ADAGE / BANAL (53A: Never say never, say / 43D: Not complicated at all). "Never say never" just didn't seem idiomatic—literally, don't say it. Don't say "never." I see now how it's got the figurative meaning of "don't give up" (whether you're actually *saying* anything or not), but still, as a bit of advice, as something posing as a truism, it felt much more like an ADAGE. And then the totally mysterious reality TV name was in there just to make matters worse. Oh, and I could not get the "R" in RUT, which would've helped with PASTRAMI for sure. Eventually JOT made me pull ADAGE for IDIOM and everything came together. The NE was similarly harrowing, if slightly less so. Again, as with SONJA in the SW, CRYPTEX (not a real thing) was gumming up the small NE corner. After I got USED TO BE, I couldn't make any of those short Acrosses work at first. And CAR TITLE, woof, no way (25A: Document for some travelers). Couldn't parse it. Had CART- and that really looked like the first part of the answer was going to be the document (a "carte" of some kind...? I dunno...). Clue is really set up to make you think of something in the "passport" or "visa" family. Finally broke through by just thinking "Where do people live by a river ... rivers ... rivers ... well, there's the Nile, that's ... D'oh!" And so EGYPT, not the stupid fictional decoding device, helped me finally decode this puzzle once and for all.


Look at this weird solving path I took today:



Came out of that NW corner with these Hail Marys that ended up being correct (!). Then instead of using them to work on that fat middle, I just dug into the opposing corner. Surprised that I could cross that great expanse with so little work. At that point, though, the hardest part of the puzzle was still to come. I don't really get how an ESSAY MILL is "seedy" (51A: Seedy business for college applicants)—I mean, it promotes fraud, but the word doesn't seem right for the context. I thought SPITFIRES had a lot of moxie, I didn't know they were especially angry or "quick-tempered" (33A: Quick-tempered sorts). I liked the surprisingly dark answer to the apparently rosy quote about "industry" by Hume (37D: "The spur of industry," according to David Hume = AVARICE). And there's lots of cleverness in the cluing. I just wish the puzzle were more entertaining overall.


Explainers:
  • 4D: Component of a sake bomb (ASAHI— a Japanese beer, common to crosswords. Sake bombs are made by dropping a shot of sake into a glass of beer.
  • 14A: ___ place (ONES)— in relation to the decimal point, there's the ONES place, the tens place, etc. (so, not "ONE'S place")
  • 36A: Big to-do? (TASK) — I guess because TASKs are on a "to-do" list? Not sure what "Big" is doing here, clue-wise. The word TASK conveys, if anything, smallness.
  • 47A: Street wear? (RUT)— because when you "wear" a street down (with your ox carts and what not) you get a RUT.
  • 7D: French open activity, for short? (PDA) — well, this is referring to kissing (a "public display of affection"). The "open" part is a stretch, because, well, good luck "French" kissing with your mouth shut. Maybe the "open" is supposed to refer to the fact that you're doing it "openly," for all to see. Still, grammatically, that's iffy. As with [Big to-do?], the "?" misdirection feels forced here. 
  • 40D: What has stories of East Asia? (PAGODA) — I knew they were buildings (usually temples or other sacred buildings), but I didn't know those buildings actually had multiple "stories." I realize now I was confusing PAGODA and GAZEBO (!?). Anyway, still got this one easily.
That's all. See you tomorrow.

Signed, Rex Parker, King of CrossWorld 

P.S. 




[Follow Rex Parker on Twitter and Facebook]

Viewing all articles
Browse latest Browse all 4351

Trending Articles



<script src="https://jsc.adskeeper.com/r/s/rssing.com.1596347.js" async> </script>