Constructor: Matthew Stock and Nam Jin YoonRelative difficulty: Medium
THEME: well, there's a "LEFT" / "RIGHT" thingie going on, but basically "none" Word of the Day: PUPUSA (
42A: Thick tortilla that's the national dish of El Salvador) —
A pupusa is a thick griddle cake or flatbread from El Salvador and Honduras, made with cornmeal or rice flour, similar to the Venezuelan and Colombian arepa. In El Salvador, it has been declared the national dish and has a specific day to celebrate it. It is usually stuffed with one or more ingredients, which may include cheese (such as quesillo or cheese with loroco buds), chicharrón, squash, or refried beans. It is typically accompanied by curtido (a spicy fermented cabbage slaw) and tomato salsa, and is traditionally eaten by hand. (wikipedia)
• • •
Not the kind of all-over fire I'm used to from Nam Jin Yoon, but still pretty good. This is more of a two-answer show, and though all the other answers are solid, and occasionally snappy, nothing comes near the slangy, colloquial heights of those two 14s:
"WHAT ELSE IS LEFT?" / "YOUR OTHER RIGHT." But the highlight ends up also being something of a lowlight, in the sense that ... the phrase is "YOUR OTHER LEFT." It just is. I don't know why it is, but it is. If you're going to do a theme (or a coy "theme," like this one) on a Friday, then there better be good reason and that theme better *land*, and "
YOUR OTHER RIGHT" just doesn't quite land. I was giddily typing in "YOUR OTHER LEFT" when I realized it wasn't going to reach. Then thought "well, I guess it's RIGHT, but that isn't ... right?" So then I looked it up, and if you google both phrases in quotation marks "right" wins by a mile, but that's only because "
YOUR OTHER RIGHT" might appear accidentally in a ton of other contexts, whereas "YOUR OTHER LEFT" ... is unique to this particular gag (which is probably what makes it the funnier / more established option). Don't believe me? Here is the "YOUR OTHER LEFT" (not "RIGHT") entry from tvtropes dot com:
If ever in a comedy somebody tells a character or a group of characters to move/turn left, you can bet the character/one or more of the group will go right instead, prompting the phrase, "Your other left!" (Or they correctly turn left, at which point the first character realizes that they actually meant to say "right" and tries to cover with the same phrase.)
If this doesn't happen, it's usually replaced with a confused exchange about "My left or your left?", even if the characters are facing the same way. [...] To be entirely fair, though, it's not like this doesn't actually happen with an alarming regularity in real life. We're just talking about its predictable appearances on TV. For some reason, it's always "your other left," never "your other right", even though you'd think both occur equally often in Real Life [...]. A likely explanation is that most people, being right handed/right dominant, will default to the right when confused, prompting "The other left". (tvtropes.com) (emph. mine)
So I like / love the energy of the answer, but primarily it's the energy of the answer that isn't actually there, the correct one, the "LEFT" one. And as for "
WHAT ELSE IS LEFT?" ... it's a plausible question, yes, but it does quite crackle with slangy specificity of, say "WHAT ELSE IS NEW?" I actually wanted "WHAT ELSE IS THERE?" to go in here, but as with "YOUR OTHER LEFT," it just didn't fit. What I'm saying is that there's a nice colloquial feel here, but the whole "theme" angle ... it doesn't really feel like they nailed it.
The NW corner is dull by comparison to the rest. I love
RESCUE DOGs, but the NE corner isn't doing a hell of a lot either. Things get much more interesting down below—also a little trickier. I really had to hang on to my hat there at the end, with
SLUICE sluicing down through *three* blank squares to complete the grid. I don't think of the
LINK as the "invite"—it takes you *to* the invite, but the
LINK itself doesn't really invite you. Never heard of
PUPUSA but after reading about them (above) they're all I want to eat right now. As for Buck
O'NEIL, once again I apologize to him for not knowing for sure if he's an -AL O'Neal or an -IL
O'NEIL (also couldn't have told you for sure if he's a one-L
O'NEIL or a two-L O'NEILL ("
he's a beast!"). Blanked on
LUNA, which seems absurd, in retrospect, since they're practically handing you the sun/
moon thing in the clue (
34D: Sibling of Sol, in Roman myth). Thought
11D: Cross was a verb and so had ANGER before
ANGRY ... which doesn't even make sense, now that I think of it. If you cross someone, sure, they might get angry, but "to cross" doesn't mean "to anger." Sigh. Wanted TRASH FIRES before
TIRE FIRES (54A: Utter disasters), since those are the metaphorical fires I've seen referred to most on social media this past decade, but TIRE FIRES are also metaphorical disasters, so thumbs up to that answer, as well as
SPACE/TIME, immediately above it (
51A: Warped fabric, it's said).
Not sure why, but I'm finding "HI ALL!" an adorable (and original) little 5 (53A: Friendly start to a group email). Always nice to find a way to bring some fresh, conversational energy to short fill. And I like the clue on SLURPEE, in the sense that I like the idea of the central answer of the puzzle just making a really disruptive noise. All the artsy intellectual types and SOCIALITEs are sipping their ROSÉ and eating canapés off of TOOTHPICKs and there's probably, I don't know, some light classical playing, maybe an actual string quartet, and then in walks some leather-clad / torn-jeans rebel who plays by their own rules, fresh from the 7-11, and right in the middle of, let's say, Vivaldi's "Spring"— "SLURRRRRRRRRP!" Cue affronted glares from the liter- and glitter- and possibly even Twitterati. End scene. What, doesn't everyone create elaborate if hackneyed movie/TV scenes from the answers in their crosswords? Ah well. I yam what I yam (to quote a famous sailor, and a recent crossword). And with that, the [Early morning caller]s are calling, so it's time to take my coffee to the porch and say hello to them: Good day.
Signed, Rex Parker, King of CrossWorld
[Follow Rex Parker on
Twitter and
Facebook]