Constructor: Kyle Dolan
Relative difficulty: Medium-Challenging
THEME: none
Word of the Day: ISFAHAN (7D: Capital of ancient Persia) —
Not my kind of puzzle. At all. Big "trivia test" energy. Not a lot of variety in this one, just the same posture of ERSATZ LEARNEDness over and over and over. Not one foreign word that is uninferable if you don't know it, but three foreign words that are uninferable if you don't know them. As a solver, I'd be happy to learn any one of these (assuming I didn't know them already), but yeesh, have some sense of proportion. You want your Saturday puzzle to be tough, OK, but there are ways you can use in addition to foreign-name trivia, there really are. I was lucky enough to know SPREZZATURA because of a dimly remembered conversation about basketball in the '90s (23D: The art of appearing effortlessly nonchalant). I am not kidding when I say that I learned this word from this one discussion about the way some commentator described some team's way of playing basketball, and I have not heard / seen this word since, but thank god it stuck because wow without it, this puzzle would've probably been next-level difficult instead of just kind of difficult (without ITALY in the NE, don't know what I'd've done up there—it's how I got started in that section). When I got SPREZZATURA, early in the solve, I actually thought that was a high point: ERSATZ SPREZZATURA WIZARDRY! That has the kind of zing I really like from my Friday puzzles and so rarely see on Saturdays.
Relative difficulty: Medium-Challenging
Word of the Day: ISFAHAN (7D: Capital of ancient Persia) —
Isfahan (Persian: اصفهان, romanized: Esfahân [esfæˈhɒːn]), from its ancient designation Aspadana and later Spahan in middle Persian, rendered in English as Ispahan, is a major city in Greater Isfahan Region, Isfahan Province, Iran. It is located 406 kilometres (252 miles) south of Tehran and is the capital of Isfahan Province. Isfahan has a population of approximately 1.9 million, making it the third-largest city in Iran, after Mashhad and Tehran, and the second-largest metropolitan area. (wikipedia)
• • •
But there was no more zing after that. Just slog. All the air went out of this one in the SW. And I guess it's worth noting that the heavily compartmentalized corners made this feel like a bunch of different puzzles rather than just one, and also meant that over and over it felt like you could just get stuck. You're in this tiny little cave and there's nowhere to go. That's what the remaining corners all felt like, especially the SW, where "___ SURE" could've been a whole bunch of things, and AURAL should've been TIDAL, and ARUM? Uh, whatever you say, I guess, and I've never thought of congee as GRUEL, though I guess technically it is ... anyway ... Sigh. The very worst thing down here, though—in fact, the only genuinely bad thing—is ALL-HEALS (56A: Herbalists' panaceas). What ... what? That is the kind of word where, when you get it, you think "that can't be right ... that's a thing?" What an incredibly stupid word. Like ... was "cure-all" not enough? You somehow needed ALL-HEALS? Just a painful revelation. Giant Thud. This puzzle had a lovely sense of SPREZZATURA but with ALL-HEALS, it's all gone. Vanished. Drained completely from the puzzle. All because of this "word." Do constructors / editors not consider what it will be like, for a solver, to turn up a word like this? It's not enough to think "it's valid!" Please consider the solver. And the solver's grave disappointment. Thank you. Moving on. . . . well the rest of the puzzle is really just OMAKASE (36A: Sushi chef's tasting menu) and ISFAHAN (7D: Capital of ancient Persia), two names I had absolutely no hope on. Again, foreign words with uninferable spellings, but this time I did not know them at all. Fun! Once again I repeat—it doesn't matter that I don't know something. It happens every day. Not mad about that part, exactly. It's just annoying that the puzzle keeps leaning on the same kind of fill, fill that presents the same kind of difficulty. SCHLEP is the word that best represents how I feel. I feel like that word feels. I feel like that word looks and sounds. Bedraggled. Working but not enjoying it.
43D: Congee, e.g. |
I'm sure many of you geniuses knew ISFAHAN and/or OMAKASE, but I am also quite certain that the general familiarity of these words is far far lower than anything else in the grid. Light years from almost anything except maybe SPREZZATURA. And yes, yes, ISFAHAN has a population of over a million people, so yes, yes, it's valid, but do you know how many cities of over a million people there are in China? Do you? And do you know how many you could name? Not you, geography trivia guy, sit down. I mean you, everyone else. Hell, do you know how many cities of four million+ you don't know? A bunch. I absolutely guarantee you, a whole bunch. DALIAN has over five million people, and I just learned of its existence right now. Again (again again), it's not about a single answer's validity, it's about a *puzzle*'s overall sense of proportion and balance. And this one just wanted to test you on trivia. And it was irksome.
I liked SPRAY TAN a lot (27A: Color not generated by light). I struggled with it a lot, and then I figured it out, and I liked figuring it out. See, difficulty can be fun! If it gets you to Aha—fun! ALL-HEALS is never, ever going to get you to fun. I keep looking at that answer and getting depressed, so I should stop. Or move on to the closing act.
Closing act:
[Follow Rex Parker on Twitter and Facebook]
Closing act:
- 21A: Where "the cheese stands alone," in a class song (DELL)— LOL what? "Classic song"!?!?! Is this "The Farmer in the DELL?" Is that the "classic song?" Oy. I honest to god wrote DELI in here, and was very satisfied with that answer. You know what I remember about "The Farmer in the DELL?" The title. I can sing the title. And then sing the title again. And then "hi ho the dairy-o" and then the title again. I am 52. Have mercy.
- 38A: Midwife's focus in the third stage of labor (PLACENTA)— nearly cheered when I got this answer. Seems like the kind of thing the NYTXW would've been squeamish about not too long ago. Credit to Julie Bérubé for being the first person to put it in a NYTXW puzzle, and thus into the databases of a lot of constructors.
- 50A: Expert with picks (MINER)— I had TUNER. I think I was imagining a tuning fork as a kind of pick (!?!?). Or else I was imagining a guitar player.
- 50D: Digital job, in brief (MANI) — manicure ... "digital" here refers to fingers.
- 28D: It started in 1964 as Blue Ribbon Sports (NIKE) — more trivia! get your piping hot trivia here! Sigh. I wanted many things here. Well "wanted" is a strong word. Words just kind of drifted into my mind, words like NASA and NYSE and ...
- 14D: Flushes, e.g., in poker (TELLS) — well I am on record as hating all things poker but as ruthless misdirects go, this clue is pretty special
[Follow Rex Parker on Twitter and Facebook]