Constructor: John Westwig
Relative difficulty: Challenging (despite the fairly basic theme gimmick)
THEME: SWITCH JOBS (56A: Change careers, or a hint to this puzzle's theme)— "___ A ___" phrases, where you have to switch the two words in the "blanks" if you want to make sense of the second half of the clue—all clues are written as want ads, with the first half indicating one kind of "job" and the second half indicating another:
Theme answers:
This started so easily. I got ADBIZ right off the bat, and that whole NW corner was filled in in about 10 seconds. This made me very, very suspicious. No Thursday should be this easy. And as soon as I tried to exit the NW, my suspiciousness was validated. I couldn't get out. Both long Acrosses headed out of that section were themers, which at that point made no sense to me. Sadly, they would not make sense to me for a while. I could not make any sense of this theme for the longest time, partly because of an error (more below) but mainly because the gimmick is so basic. I was looking for ... I don't know, something tricky that would really make the weird clues make sense. But what I ended up getting was phrases where the first and last words simply switch places. And simple themes can be beautiful, they really can, but the results here are so corny, or forced, or awkward, or just ... off, that the whole theme experience was just one cringe after another. The phrases are so rarely on the money. TRAIN A RIDE does not feel spot-on for horse-training, and RIDE A TRAIN!?!? Is that what you think conductors do. Just ... ride. *I* RIDE A TRAIN. Me, the passenger. I hope to god the conductor is doing something more than just riding. Similarly, I hope whoever is "flying" the plane has more experience with planes than merely boarding them. And the want ad concept ... it just didn't work. Once again, instead of the theme being a clear, joyful revelation, it ends up being one where you really gotta call in the lawyers and explainers. Fussy and unpleasant.
Relative difficulty: Challenging (despite the fairly basic theme gimmick)
Theme answers:
- TRAIN A RIDE (=> ride a train)(17A: "Equestrian is wanted to ... / Experience needed: conducting")
- MOVE A BUST (=> bust a move) (12D: "Museum curator is wanted to ... / Experience needed: freestyle dancing")
- DEAL A STRIKE (=> strike a deal) (23A: "Baseball pitcher is wanted to ... Experience needed: negotiating")
- PLANE A BOARD (=> board a plane) (46A: "Carpenter is wanted to ... / Experience needed: flying")
- CHECK A CUT (=> cut a check) (31D: "Nurse is wanted to ... / Experience needed: philanthropy")
Plastique is a supervillain appearing in American comic books published by DC Comics. She is an enemy of Firestorm and both an enemy and love interest of Captain Atom. (wikipedia)
• • •
The fill was also quite unpleasant in many places. Who in the world is PLASTIQUE!!? LOL, I just spent the last six weeks teaching superhero comics and I've literally never heard of PLASTIQUE. If you read her wikipedia page, you'll see, there's not a ton of reason for me ever to have heard of her. And if *I* haven't heard of her, it seems, let's say, probable, that a sizable chunk of NYTXWsolverland isn't going to have a clue. Of course many of you won't have known ZENDAYA either, but you don't have as much to complain about there, as she is very (if fairly recently) famous (she won the Emmy for "Euphoria," an HBO show that I learned only recently is really really popular with college students; it's one of HBO's most popular series ever). Older solvers will have to content themselves with Danny KAYE and Mortimer SNERD. Speaking of names, just a gruesome one-two punch with ELON and RUBIO. Then there's the downer of REPO and the really badly timed super-downer of TOTAL WAR. Then there's the not-at-all foreign-language words, TUO (slightly rough if you don't know Italian) and HAEC, dear lord, HAEC, I studied Latin for a bit and forgot HAEC was a thing. And it's clued in a phrase I've never heard of. I just kept wanting the clue to be [In ___ veritas] so I could write in VINO and move on. Oof, HAEC. And who calls it GAY LIB!?!? Women's Lib, Gay Pride. I can figure out what is meant by GAY LIB, obviously, but I don't think it ever had the widespread currency that WOMEN'S LIB did. Also, like WOMEN'S LIB, it's a dated phrase. Anyway, I knew what Stonewall was, obviously, but LIB, yeah, did not see that coming. The worst mistake I made, though, by far, was writing in PRAT for ARSE (18D: Brit's bottom). I'm not even sure Brits say that. And wow, if you're gonna make a mistake, maybe don't make it in the answer that crosses the *one letter* ("A") that is going to be most crucial to your understanding the theme. Hard to see the "blank A blank" pattern when your "A" isn't there. Also, if you've got PRAT where ARSE should be, you get TRAIN PRIDE, and honestly, that seemed very right. A conductor should have TRAIN PRIDE, and the equestrian ... I don't know, maybe the horse's name is PRIDE?? Or else the equestrian will also be doubling as a lion tamer.
SAD SIGHT was tough, as I had SAD STATE and then later considered SAD SIGNS and SAD SIGHS before SAD SIGHT ever occurred to me. But perhaps the toughest struggle came with LOWKEY (24D: Chill), a perfectly good answer clued in a perfectly good way except, ugh, OYEZ, what is happening there!? It's a horrible little answer to begin with, and then you get cute with the clue and the horribleness just goes up exponentially (27A: Hearing disorder remedy?). So I guess ... there's a trial ... and something causes "disorder" in the court ... and maybe the bailiff shouts "OYEZ"!!? (it's an exclamation that essentially means "hear ye, hear ye"). But I can't blame OYEZ for my LOWKEY screwup. For that, I have to go to SCHWA, and a little bit to "OH, OK." I had the "S" and "A" at 30A: It begins "again" and didn't even hesitate to write in SOFT A. I'm not even sure that's a real thing, but I've seen "hard" letters (HARDG, for example), so I thought "well, I've got the "S" and the "A," so why not?" Well, "why not?" is because it's wrong. The SOFT also meant I got into trouble with 32D: Alarms—I wanted FIRE BELLS (!?!) instead of HORRIFIES. In short, there was not one section of this grid where the solving experience felt smooth or delightful. A slog from start to finish, despite the inclusion of some nice (NOICE!) fill here and there. Corny theme, depressing fill. This week has been particularly off. The themes just haven't landed right at all. Really looking forward to cleaning my palate with some crisp themelesses this weekend, and then ... well, I'm on vacation most of next week, so other people will be writing about the puzzles while I get some much-needed puzzle-free time. But in the meantime .... see you tomorrow.
Signed, Rex Parker, King of CrossWorld
[Follow Rex Parker on Twitter and Facebook]
Signed, Rex Parker, King of CrossWorld
[Follow Rex Parker on Twitter and Facebook]