Constructor: Blake Slonecker
Relative difficulty: Easy
THEME: NBA / JAM (38A: With 39-Across, classic sports video game ... or a hint to four squares in this puzzle) — "NBA" is "JAM"med into four squares in this puzzle:
Theme answers:
Well, for a puzzle that began with the clue [Taradiddle] (i.e. with cloying quaintness), this one turned out OK. The theme was really, really simple—simple conceptually, simple to uncover—but somehow it was still fun discovering all the "NBA"-containing answers, which were By Far the most interesting things in the grid. Figuring out it was a rebus went something like this. A. realize that it is Thursday, which is the most likely rebus day of the week; B. Get to [Regain, as affection], realize it has to be WIN-something, but there aren't enough spaces for any answer to make sense; C. get the "K" from DANKE (4D: Counterpart of "Bitte"), realize the cross *has* to be WIN BACK; D. see that "NBA" (a meaningful entity) can fit in one square; E. make it fit. That's probably a few letters too many, it all happened so fast, but hopefully you can see how the rebus came into view. By far the most important solving step in that progression is A: if you don't know to look for rebuses, don't at least have them on your radar, then a puzzle like this can, of course, destroy you. But if you were aware of the possibility, then this one was very easy to see. I hit the revealer shortly thereafter, which told me that "NBA" would be the only letter sequence I'd be looking for (before that I thought I might have to hunt down the initials of all four major U.S. sports leagues). I knew what NBA JAM was, which was undoubtedly a huge advantage in solving this thing quickly. Very easy to discover, and repetitive in its expression (NBANBANBAetc.), and yet, as I say, those "NBA" answers are all pretty delightful. While I like BEANBAG CHAIRS as an answer, points off for not breaking "NBA" across the two words in the answer (as all the other longer theme answers do—actually, SUSAN B. ANTHONY breaks across *three* elements). But eight pleasing theme answers, no clunkers, that's not bad.
Cluing beefs:
[Follow Rex Parker on Twitter and Facebook]
Relative difficulty: Easy
Theme answers:
- NEWBORN BABIES / FANBASE (18A: They're swaddled and coddled / 9D: Beliebers or the Beyhive, for instance)
- BEANBAG CHAIRS / WIN BACK (3D: Seats that sink / 20A: Regain, as affection)
- SUSAN B. ANTHONY / PINBALL (58A: Co-founder of the women's rights newspaper The Revolution / 53D: Bumper-to-bumper activity?)
- CANADIAN BACON / GUN BANS (26D: Eggs Benedict component / 57A: Some measures championed by the March for Our Lives movement)
Leopold von Auer (Hungarian: Auer Lipót; June 7, 1845 – July 15, 1930) was a Hungarian violinist, academic, conductor and composer, best known as an outstanding violin teacher. [...] Auer is remembered as one of the most important pedagogues of the violin, and was one of the most sought-after teachers for gifted students. "Auer's position in the history of violin playing is based on his teaching." Many notable virtuoso violinists were among his students, including Mischa Elman, Konstanty Gorski, Jascha Heifetz, Nathan Milstein, Toscha Seidel, Efrem Zimbalist, Georges Boulanger, Benno Rabinof, Kathleen Parlow, Julia Klumpke, Thelma Given, Sylvia Lent, Kemp Stillings, and Oscar Shumsky. Among these were "some of the greatest violinists" of the twentieth century. (wikipedia)
• • •
My only displeasures today came in the editing / cluing. Well, and AUER. AUER is a name I associate with very very bygone puzzles. It brings its own mustiness. I know it only because of crosswords. The NYT mistook Leopold for (actor) Mischa one time, over a decade ago, and let me tell you, it's bad enough not knowing who the AUERs are. When the crossword can't even keep them straight, that's just depressing. Well, I've at least seen Mischa AUER in movies by now (My Man Godfrey is particularly exceptional). You see LAILA, ENSLER, LES PAUL, and ASNER, you think OK, I see you people all the time, but you're familiar enough that I can just wave and move on. Whereas with AUER, I was very conscious of knowing something (because of past crossword trauma) that a huge percentage of the solving base just wouldn't know. Not a great feeling. You'd think I'd throw my hands in the air in triumph, knowing a relatively obscure thing. But that's not how my brain works. AUER and [Taradiddle] just gave me bad vibes. Musty Puzzles of Yore vibes. Perhaps you're thinking, "your stupid bad vibes are not worth a SOU!" That does sound like something an AUER stan would say. But anyway, AUER had fair crosses, though, so I / you probably shouldn't complain too much.
Cluing beefs:
- 1A: Taradiddle (FIB)— did I mention I hate this clue word? Also making this 1-Across experience unpleasant: I knew what "taradiddle" meant (because, again, of past crossword trauma ... editor likes this word, for some reason) ... buuuuut I wrote in LIE. And "confirmed" LIE with ICHIRO. Because of course. That seems like the kind of annoying thing that would happen in and around the stupid word "taradiddle."
- 21D: Garden item that can be brined, informally (CUKE) — cluing CUKE as an "item" is fraud, if not violence. Living things are not "items." Organic matter, not an "item." Your dog is not a household "item." Bread is not a kitchen "item." Inanimate objects are "items." Tools are "items." So the only thing I wanted here was a garden tool. So much so that I was struggling to understand why anyone would brine, say, a hoe. But then the answer was just CUKE. Awful.
- 16A: Out now, in a way (AIRED)— the clue makes it sound like it is currently available, or in progress. AIRED is decidedly and emphatically past tense. It's just such a clumsy, unpleasant, awkward way to create difficulty.
- 66A: Divisions of a krone (ØRE) —why? Why would you do this to poor ORE? You've already got SOU in the grid. How many people must suffer for your crossword currency fetish!?
- 27D: State (AVER)— I have no problem with this clue, actually. I just want to register again my distaste for the tiresome AV-- dilemma. Is it AVOW!? Is it AVER!? Least interesting dilemma of all time (after the [Mauna ___] dilemma).
[Follow Rex Parker on Twitter and Facebook]